7 Quick Tips for Cleaning Up After a Party Water Rings Image 2 of 7 Try rubbing a bit of non-gel toothpaste onto a water ring, then buff with a clean cloth. You can also substitute full-fat mayonnaise for the toothpaste; leave it on for at least an hour before wiping clean and buffing. You Might Also Like... The Art of Crafting Flavorful Party Bites: Gourmet Slider Recipes Everything You Need to Know About Mezcal The Ultimate Guide to Buying the Best Ribeye Steaks You’re my Lucky Charm Pantry Staples Breakfast Favorites